During Critique for Presenters
1) Display Necessary Information
- Pin work up, use screens, hand out papers, etc.
2) Deliver Clear Presentation
- Explain design rationale & design context
- Be careful to not over-present your design. You want your audience to see your design without any prejudice
3) Ask Questions
- Let the Critic know what you’re having trouble with
- Be specific about what kind of critique you’d like to receive and what you don’t want at this stage
4) Be Open to Responses
- Don‘t expect good responses from the start, and try not to be defensive and don’t interrupt the Critic when he / she is speaking
- Invite objective criticism if Critics are too nice
- Rephrase each question before answering it
- If the Critic asks a question or gives a comment you don’t understand, ask for clarification – being on the same page is important
- Ask why issues raised are of concern and write down actionable suggestions received
- Listen for possibilities and issues that aren’t present in your current thinking
- Make sure the feedback is relevant to the questions you asked
- Take notes or have someone take notes for you
- Be positive and polite
5) Thank the Critic(s)
- Ex: “Thank you for all the feedback, I will think about all of them”
6) Learn from Critiques of Others’ Work
- Pay attention and take notes on comments that are relevant to your artifact
- Become a Critic and actively participate